The Apiary Network
theapiarybanner.jpg
« Inside With: Brian Huskey, Writer, Improviser | Main | John Mayer Totally Comfortable Using Racist Slurs In Stand Up Premiere »

June 26, 2006

A History of Eating It

There's a nice profile today in the New York Post about the granny of all modern NYC alt-comedy showcases, Eating It.

In preparing the article for the Post, reporter (and writer/comedian) Mandy Stadtmiller had leftover a fascinating timeline of performers and highlights that Eating It founder Jeff Singer produced for her. Did you know Eating It did a "webcast" all the way back in the year 1999? Must of been like watching cavemen try to control fire. Webcasts, lol.

The first few years of Eating It are below, the rest continue AFTER THE BLOOMP. Eating It is tonight on Pier 63 @ 8PM.

1997-1998
-Night of 100 Stars hosted by Matt Walsh & Leo Allen
-Stephen Colbert
-Lewis Black
-Mary Lynn Rajskub (now on "24")
-Benjamin & Lee bring up male strippers
-Upright Citizens Brigade (Amy Poehler, Matt Besser, Ian Roberts, Matt Walsh)

First Timers: Andy Blitz, Demetri Martin, Nick Swardson


1998-1999
-Season of experimenting with co-hosts:

Colette Hawley & Steven Lynch
Greg Fitzsimmons & Laura D.
Hugh Fink & Kevin Brennan
Marc Maron & Reverend Jen
Todd Barry & Jonathan Groff
Guest spot by Janeane Garofalo & Craig Bierko

-Louis C.K's "Filthy Stupid Talent Show" featuring Ron Lynch; a comic who does "high energy"; and a guy who only wrestles Jews; later became a Comedy Central special.

-Slovin & Allen host with their heads submerged in a fish tank.

First Timers: Patrick Borelli, Tom Shillue, Eddie Pepitone


1999-2000
-Kids in the Hall interview webcast
-Robert Schimmel
-Dave Chappelle
-David Cross

- Jon Benjamin & John Glaser's Father's Day Show, co-hosted be each of their Dads from Boston and Detroit respectively on speakerphone.

First timers: Christian Finnegan, Brody Stevens, Jonathan Corbett, Rick Shapiro


2000-2001
-Hugh Fink & Enemies show with Steven Schirripa, Louis C.K., Wanda Sykes, Colin Quinn, Janeane Garofalo and violinist Joshua Bell; show later appeared at Montreal Just Laughs Comedy Festival
-1st "Reading It" show with John Hodgman, Sarah Vowell, Jerry Stahl. Future alumni include Amy Sedaris, Stephen Colbert & Paul Dinello, Melissa Bank, Eric Bogosian, David Rakoff, Matthew Klam, Amy Sohn, Augusten Burroughs
- Patrick Borelli brings a monkey to show as part of his act, gets bitten on ear and rushes to hospital before ever performing.
-Patton Oswalt
-Nick Di Paolo
-Matt Besser hosting as Keith Privett, the first and only male waiter at Hooters

First timers: Jonathan Ames, Mike Birbiglia, Naked Babies (w Rob Corrdry)


2001-2002
-Jon Benjamin's cousin's Bar Mitzvah. Theme show done entirely like a real Bar Mitzvah, complete with Bar Mitzvah boy, DJ spinning music, and party games.
-Todd Barry's speed dates. Todd Barry performs then speed dates 8 different women live on stage.
-60 in 60, featuring 60 comedians/acts performing in 60 minutes.
-First "Confessing It" show created/hosted by Colette Hawley with Marc Maron, Sarah Silverman, Roseanne Barr;
future alumni include Janeane Garofalo, Colin Quinn, Robert Schimmel, Jonathan Ames, Patton Oswalt, Scott Thompson, Louis C.K.; "Confessing It" later produced 4 consecutive years at Montreal Just For Laughs Festival and produced as two TV pilots for Comedy Central.

First timers: Dave Gorman, Bill Burr, Ed Helms, Fred Armisen, Kristen Schaal


2002-2003
-Jeff Garlin
-Susie Essman
-Rich Hall
-Laura Kightlinger
-Jim Gaffigan
-Andy Kindler
-First "Dating It" show, appearing this summer for the 4th year at the Montreal Comedy Festival. Also produced in other cities across North America including Vancouver and Minneapolis.

First timers: Neil Brennan, Morgan Murphy


2003-2004
-Joe Rogan
-Scott Thompson
-Graham Norton
-Greg Proops
-Jim Norton's memorable confession at "Confessing It"

First Timers: Mike O'Connell, Jay Oakerson, Nick Kroll, Andy Borowtiz


2004-2005
Tommy Tiernan
Dom Irrera

-Last show at Luna Lounge, Jan 31, 2005
-First show at Zipper Theater, Feb 28, 2005 (Eating It becomes monthly)
-Oddest co-hosting match-up: Steve Schirripa & Andy Blitz

-First Show at Pier 63, Sept 19, 2005

-First timers: Rob Pue, Michael Somerville, Lizzy Cooperman


2006
First full summer season at Pier 63.

Posted by The Apiary at June 26, 2006 2:22 PM

Comments

Are you making AFTER THE BLOOMP happen?

That's fetch.

Posted by: Carolyn at June 26, 2006 4:54 PM

I've got big plans for the BLOOMP.

Posted by: Nate at June 26, 2006 5:44 PM

DID YOU KNOW: the night of 100 stars was filmed and released on vhs?

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0970162812/qid=1151379148/sr=8-5/ref=sr_1_5/103-2158964-0668625?%5Fencoding=UTF8&v=glance&n=404272

Maybe 3 or 4 years back there was a used copy on the amazon marketplace for a staggering $192. I guess someone finally shelled it out. Someone needs to make it available.

Posted by: hound at June 26, 2006 11:35 PM

Timeline was great. But the writer - of course, a "comedian" (and if you want to know how the world works, click her link above and note that they let her go on last night) - bought into the pr bullshit that a monthly show somehow affords greater opportunities for eccentricity, chanced-taking and exciting line-ups, which flies in the face of reality.

Posted by: Andrew J. Lederer at June 27, 2006 9:01 AM

I meant chance-taking.

Posted by: Andrew J. Lederer at June 27, 2006 9:03 AM

"Did you know Eating It did a "webcast" all the way back in the year 1999? Must of been like watching cavemen try to control fire. Webcasts, lol. "

Thin ice Apiary... I hosted many times at Luna, including that webcast. (And if you don't lay off I'll hit you with my club and yell, "ook ook ooooook!")

Posted by: Susie at June 27, 2006 10:58 AM

Hey Andrew, Colette asked me to do a bit with her last night. I didn't ask to go up. "Also" the Chicago Tribune has "written" about me as a "comedian" so I'm not a complete retard for identifying myself as such. Partial retard, sure. At the very least, I'm glad I helped show how the world works.

Posted by: Mandy Stadtmiller at June 27, 2006 1:10 PM

Mandy - I'm sure you're very nice and I had neither right nor sufficient knowledge to cast aspersions on your comedic credentials, so forgive me for that. (I kinda meant it more symbolically than specifically, anyway.)

But I do think the Post article read, to a great extent, like unexamined pr. In particular, the point I singled out begs questioning -- how is it that a monthly show (and limited to a summer run at that) can possibly offer more opportunity for innovation, new talent, etc. than a weekly effort. (If there's an answer other than, "It can't," or "Well, they told me it could," it would have been instructive to see it included.)

I can't afford to make more enemies, so trust me, there's nothing personal in this. (Not in my feelings toward you, at any rate.) But having Jeff Singer's wife invite you to do something with her on the show the very day you've published a piece about said show is a lesson in how the world works.


Respectfully,
Andrew


Posted by: Andrew J. Lederer at June 27, 2006 2:07 PM

I'm kind of a dick, really, but thanks for that. And you're right. You don't see enough investigative pieces on why a comedy show goes from weekly to monthly. Pitch it somewhere. I'll read it.

Posted by: Mandy Stadtmiller at June 27, 2006 3:50 PM

And you're right. You don't see enough investigative pieces on why a comedy show goes from weekly to monthly. Pitch it somewhere. I'll read it.

Posted by: Mandy Stadtmiller at June 27, 2006 03:50 PM

*****************************************


Now, now . . . You know that's not what I was suggesting.


It's just that I thought that one assertion seemed kinda ridiculous when I read the article in the paper, so when I saw this Apiary post, I thought -- "Oh, boy. Now, I can make my big, important point!"


It was, in my mind, rhetorical in the extreme; a tree falling in the forest.


So, of course, it turned out otherwise and at a time when I'm anything but in the mood to make a sound.

One thing I do wanna say, though --


It occurred to me while I was out a little while ago (I do get out) that you thought I was accusing you of some kind of corruption with my little seeing "how the world works" remark. I can honestly say I never thought that; never considered there was any quid pro quo in exchange for you being on the show or anything like that.

I was just referring to the basic, small-scale cronyism that permeates pretty much everything in life. I'm not necessarily against it. I have most definitely benefited from it. It's simply the way it is.

Posted by: Andrew J. Lederer at June 27, 2006 4:53 PM

What do you want from this girl? How can you come here and argue these ridiculous points when the entire paper drips with corrupt journalists (page 6), bs right-wing bias, and the most exploitative cover stories you'll ever see? And you publicly admit to buying this rag?? Read The Times for godssakes, you dimwitted cheapskate.

Posted by: Leroy at June 27, 2006 5:18 PM

Is this the quote that drove you insane:

"What's more, the formerly weekly show has gone monthly, allowing for a more planned-out and eclectic mix of performers."

?

I'm not a producer, but I would argue that 30 days DOES equate to more planning time than 7 days.

Posted by: Nate at June 27, 2006 5:27 PM

Yeah. I went looking for the quote a little while ago, which -- when I read it in the paper -- really annoyed me. (Sheepishly) Does seem kinda small now.

I think "more eclectic" is what seemed preposterous to me. Equally likely, the quote summoned to mind all of the ridiculous claims I always read in these articles that go unchallenged by the writers.


At the time that I read it, I didn't know I was going to comment on it; it was just a reaction to something I read in the paper. Shouldda read it again before I did comment, though, 'cause even if it is an example of the regurgitated pr I hate, it's a pretty mild and inoffensive one.


But it's probable that my feelings for the Eating It enterprise in general seeped into my reaction as well.


I confess to a certain schadenfreude when it comes to the show's recent travails. The reasons are not worth getting into here and I had no intention of dissing the show in my comments (and I didn't), but I think the "disinformation" I perceived in the original article was probably magnified by my negative predisposition.

I did the show a bunch of times during a relatively brief period and I don't do it anymore and whether I am to blame for that or not, it creates a prism within me through which I view all Eating It-related items. Said prism's refractions have this time 'round enveloped me in bullshit.

I will shut up now.

Except -- oh, yeah -- my original complaints about regurgitated pr still apply. (Again sheepish) Just not to this.

Posted by: Andrew J. Lederer at June 27, 2006 6:32 PM

And you publicly admit to buying this rag?? Read The Times for godssakes, you dimwitted cheapskate.

Posted by: Leroy at June 27, 2006 05:18 PM
******************************************
Post is only 25 cents, so the cheapskate part is right on the money (so to speak). I would, however, argue that I am a quickwitted cheapskate.


Also, the Post is compact and easy to tote.


And it doesn't have an obituary page, so I don't have to have perfectly good days ruined by the news someone I admire has died. You read the Times obit page, you end up regretting the deaths of people you never even heard of.

Posted by: Andrew J. Lederer at June 27, 2006 6:39 PM

Andrew's actually right about the regurgitated PR. I interned at a PR firm that repped a big show at the Javits center every year. The Post printed word for word an article my boss wrote for them and then credited a Post reporter. Funny shite.

Posted by: thetruth at June 27, 2006 10:50 PM

I've worked at a bunch of newspapers around the country, and I've seen that happen everywhere. This piece, I must say, is pure reporting. Including my crack divination of the more planned out lineup allowed via a monthly show.

Posted by: Mandy Stadtmiller at June 28, 2006 2:21 AM

Post a comment




Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)